After two years of D1 hockey, Tony Fischer moved from Colorado back to Minnesota where he was recruited by the Tooth Fairies, a University of Minnesota intramural hockey team comprised mainly of dental school students. He led the Fairies to third place in the IM championship while leading the league in penalty minutes and game misconducts. "I remember kicking some history major's ass in the semi-finals. I got thrown out and it cost us a shot in the finals, but it was worth it."